Join Stacy of Real Everything and Dr. Sarah of The Paleo Mom as they bust myths and answer your questions about a nontoxic lifestyle, nutrient-dense diet, Autoimmune Protocol, and parenting.
Friday Apr 23, 2021
Friday Apr 23, 2021
Friday Apr 23, 2021
The Whole View, Episode 453: Should We Eat Breakfast Before 8:30am?
Welcome back to episode 453! (0:28)
Stacy reminds listeners that science is an evolutionary process and, like life, things are constantly changing and growing.
The Whole View has years of shows that may contain outdated science. Both Stacy and Sarah feel it's important to bring some of these episodes back to the forefront and re-examine how science has changed.
So in honor of revisiting some of our favorite shows with the updated science, Sarah decided to start with re-examining the science behind eating (or not eating) breakfast before 8:30am.
See Episode 381: Is Breakfast the Most Important Meal of the Day? for more notes from the last episode!
Stacy reminds listeners that when you go through long periods of not eating (intermittently fasting), it signals to your body that it's time to rest. This can mess with your circadian rhythm. (58:26)
Studies link eating breakfast can lower stress levels, help manage mental health, and improve physical health.
Stacy also reminds listeners that coffee doesn't count as breakfast and can actually inflame stomach issues.
You can also spread out breakfast throughout the morning "breakfast" window by eating a series of small things.
Endocrinology Conference: Breakfast Before 8:30am
The study was designed to look at restricted feeding, comparing shorter windows to loger windows. (1:04:20)
Previous studies have found that time-restricted eating, which consolidates eating to a shortened time frame each day, has consistently demonstrated improved metabolic health.
But research shows that an early time-restricted feeding window is better:
- TPV Podcast Episode 386: Intermittent Fasting
- Intermittent Fasting: Secret to Weight Loss or Dangerous Fad?
Researchers analyzed data from 10,575 adults who participated in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey.
They divided participants into three groups depending on the total duration of food intake: less than 10 hours, 10-13 hours, and more than 13 hours per day.
Then, they created six subgroups based on eating duration start time (before or after 8:30 am).
They analyzed this data to determine if eating duration and timing were associated with fasting blood sugar levels and estimated insulin resistance.
Fasting blood sugar levels did not differ significantly among eating interval groups.
Insulin resistance was higher with shorter eating interval duration but lower across all groups with an eating start time before 8:30am.
What they discovered instead was that eating breakfast early reduced insulin resistance, and feeding window didn't matter.
- Is Breakfast the Most Important Meal of the Day?
- Is Breakfast The Most Important Meal of the Day? New Science Has Answers!
People who start eating before 8:30 am had lower blood sugar levels and less insulin resistance. This could reduce the risk of developing type 2 diabetes.
Sarah surmises that it makes sense from a cortisol vs. insulin perspective!
Breakfast & Cortisol
Stress, breakfast cereal consumption, and cortisol: recent research has shown that regular breakfast cereal consumption is associated with lower stress levels and reports of better physical and mental health.
The present study examined this issue using an objective indicator of stress, salivary cortisol.
Results showed that stress was associated with higher cortisol levels, and daily consumption of breakfast cereal was associated with lower cortisol levels.
Another study showed female breakfast-skippers display a disrupted cortisol rhythm and elevated blood pressure.
Not to mention, chronic stress is associated with indicators of diet quality in habitual breakfast skippers.
New Science About Breakfast Before 8:30am
Skipping breakfast is also associated with cancer-related and all-cause mortality in a national cohort of United States adults.
Data associates habitual nightly fasting duration, eating timing, and eating frequency with cardiometabolic risk in women.
Association between Breakfast Consumption and Depressive Symptoms among Chinese College Students: A Cross-Sectional and Prospective Cohort Study.
The ORs (95% CI) for depressive symptoms with decreasing breakfast consumption frequency were 1.00 (reference) for ≥6 times/week, 2.045 (1.198, 3.491) for 2-5 times/week, and 2.722 (0.941, 7.872) for ≤1 time/week (p for trend: 0.005).
Changing any sort of habit can be difficult, and Stacy reminds the audience that it won't be the easiest fix if you're not a breakfast person. (1:13:50)
She tries planning ahead by hard boiling eggs to grab and go in the morning. Stacy also makes a lot of smoothies in the morning using whole fruit.
If you haven't joined Patreon yet, now is a great time! It supports this show and gives you behind-the-scenes content, including how Sarah and Stacy really feel about these revisiting episodes.
Thanks so much for listening, and we will see you next week!